Your consultation notes say “rib cartilage graft” and the quote has one extra line for it. How much will the chest hurt, and for how long?
Key takeaways
- In a 2026 study of 40 patients, chest pain after rib cartilage harvest averaged 4.15 to 5.10 out of 10 on day 1 and 0.0 to 0.1 by day 30.
- Scar scores in a 36-patient series with an incision under 1.5 cm averaged 1.28 on a 0 to 13 scale at 6 months, where 0 is normal skin.
- A pooled review of 21 studies found a collapsed lung in 0.1% of patients and severe donor-site pain in 0.2%, so serious chest problems are rare but not zero.
- How the cartilage is taken changes the pain, so the technique belongs on your question list next to the incision length.
Published studies describe chest pain from rib cartilage harvest as highest between the first hours and the first week, and mostly gone within a few weeks in the nose-surgery series; one ear-surgery series reports pain and clicking easing over 3 months. In a 2026 study of 40 patients, average pain scores fell from about 4 to 5 out of 10 on day 1 to near zero by day 30. A pooled review of 21 studies found severe donor-site pain in 0.2% of patients and a collapsed lung in 0.1%. These are averages from particular surgeons and techniques, so they cannot predict your own recovery.
A costal (rib) cartilage graft is a piece of cartilage taken from the front of the rib cage through a small skin cut and used in the nose. The harvest site is called the donor site. Where rib sits among the other sources is covered in our guide to nasal cartilage grafts.
How painful is the chest after rib cartilage harvest, and for how long?
Studies put the worst pain between the first hours and the first week, then a steady fall. The figures differ because each team measured something slightly different, so read the rows as separate pictures.
| Study | Patients | Measured | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gan and colleagues, 2026 | 40 women, rhinoplasty | Pain, 0 to 10, on days 1, 3, 7, 14, 30 | Joints beside the harvested rib kept: 4.15, 1.95, 0.80, 0.05, 0.0. Joints not kept: 5.10, 2.85, 1.40, 0.2, 0.1 |
| Song and colleagues, 2023 | 23 women, rhinoplasty after breast augmentation | Pain scale; scar at 1 year | Pain peaked 12 hours after surgery, then fell; all were satisfied with the scar |
| Uppal and colleagues, 2008 | 42, ear reconstruction | Questionnaire on pain and chest clicking | Pain and clicking were the most common complaints, peaked in week 1 and faded slowly over 3 months |
| Yang and colleagues, 2015 | 151, ear surgery (mastoid) | Pain duration and score | Noticeable pain lasted 5.3 days on average; 3.0 out of 10 on day 1 |
Only the first two rows are nose surgery. The other two are chest-wall harvests for ear operations, included because the wound is the same kind. The patients, surgeons and pain relief differ from study to study, and pain is self-reported.
“Chest clicking” in the Uppal series is a click of the chest wall reported by patients. It is a separate matter from the nose clicking some people notice later, which is covered in why the nose makes clicking sounds after rhinoplasty.
How big is the chest scar?
Newer techniques report small incisions. A 2023 series from Naples of 36 septorhinoplasty patients used an incision under 1.5 cm. Scar scores on the Vancouver Scar Scale (0 is normal skin, 13 is the worst imaginable) averaged 1.53 at one week and 1.28 at six months.
Song and colleagues assessed the donor scar at one year in 23 women who had earlier breast augmentation, and all were satisfied. That is a small group from one hospital. Neither study says how a scar will look on your skin, because scarring depends on the person.
If a chest scar matters to you, ask where the cut will sit and how long it will be. The answer is easier to compare between quotes before the operation than to discover after it.

What can go wrong at the donor site?
Serious problems are uncommon in the pooled data. A 2015 systematic review in Aesthetic Surgery Journal by Varadharajan and colleagues pooled 21 studies of rib cartilage in rhinoplasty. Donor-site rates were:
- pneumothorax (air leaking between the lung and chest wall, which can collapse the lung): 0.1%
- pleural tear (a break in the lining around the lung): 0.6%
- infection: 0.6%
- seroma (a pocket of fluid under the skin): 0.6%
- scar-related problems: 2.9%
- severe donor-site pain: 0.2%
The Naples series reported two patients followed up for pneumothorax out of 36 and no infections. Percentages from pooled reviews and counts from one small series will not match, and neither tells you your own risk.
The same review counted problems in the nose itself, such as warping of the graft (5.2%). Our guide to what studies report about taking rib cartilage puts those numbers next to the 2015 meta-analysis by Wee and colleagues.
Does the way the cartilage is taken change recovery?
Yes, in the studies that compared techniques or described a different one. The evidence is mostly single-surgeon series, so use it as a list of things to ask.
- Keeping the joints. Gan and colleagues took the sixth rib cartilage and, in 20 of 40 patients, kept the joints with the fifth and seventh. Pain was lower on every day measured, and cartilage length was about the same (33.2 mm versus 32.45 mm).
- Taking the central part only. Lee and colleagues reported 322 rhinoplasty cases in which only the central segment was taken, leaving cartilage intact on three sides. They reported an average operation time of 10 minutes, one seroma, and minimal pain and scarring. One surgeon’s own review of his own cases leans favourable, so it is a lead rather than proof.
- Other routes. A 2024 review by Bagunaid and colleagues describes harvesting the seventh rib as the usual approach and lists the 10th rib, harvesting through the navel with an endoscope, and fresh-frozen donor rib as ways surgeons try to reduce complications.
Donor rib avoids the chest wound altogether. It comes with its own questions about warping and resorption, laid out in our guide to cadaver rib cartilage.
What should you ask before agreeing to a rib graft?
Ask the surgeon who will do the harvest, and get the answers written into the quote. Six questions cover it:
- Why is rib needed for my nose, and is the septum, ear or donor rib not enough? See revision rhinoplasty if this is a second operation.
- Which rib, how much cartilage, and with what technique?
- How long will the chest incision be, and where will it sit?
- What pain relief is planned for the chest, and how is it different from the nose?
- Who looks at the chest wound if something is wrong after I fly home? See travel after nose surgery and flying after a nose job.
- What does the price include if the graft plan changes during surgery? The Turkey rhinoplasty cost guide lists the other line items.
The printable clinic checklist has space for the answers, and how to choose a surgeon covers the wider comparison. Time away from work is a separate calculation: see how long off work after rhinoplasty.
Sources
Pages checked 19 November 2026.
- Gan Y and colleagues, A new concept of costal cartilage harvest in the reduction of postoperative pain at donor site, Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2026.
- Song Z and colleagues, Costal cartilage harvest through a small incision in Asian rhinoplasty after breast augmentation, Journal of Craniofacial Surgery, 2023.
- Uppal RS and colleagues, Donor-site morbidity after autologous costal cartilage harvest in ear reconstruction, Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2008.
- Yang HC and colleagues, Donor-site morbidity following minimally invasive costal cartilage harvest technique, Clinical and Experimental Otorhinolaryngology, 2015.
- Committeri U and colleagues, Minimally invasive harvesting technique for costal cartilage graft, Journal of Clinical Medicine, 2023.
- Varadharajan K and colleagues, Complications associated with the use of autologous costal cartilage in rhinoplasty, Aesthetic Surgery Journal, 2015.
- Lee M and colleagues, Central segment harvest of costal cartilage in rhinoplasty, Laryngoscope, 2011.
- Bagunaid MA and colleagues, Harvesting costal cartilage for secondary rhinoplasty, Cureus, 2024.
- Wee JH and colleagues, Complications associated with autologous rib cartilage use in rhinoplasty: a meta-analysis, JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery, 2015.



